Week of November 7-13
- Defensive: Ethan Lane, Maranatha
- Offensive: Jesse Muldrow, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Special Teams: Travis Turnquist, Wisconsin Lutheran
Week of October 31-November 6
- Defensive: Jamel Gray, Concordia Chicago
- Offensive: John Borsellino, Benedictine
- Special Teams: Broc Lawry, Lakeland
Week of October 24-30
- Defensive: Eric Zeitler, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Offensive: Jake Koehler, Concordia Chicago
- Special Teams: Billy Dixon, Benedictine
Week of October 17-23
- Defensive: Tony Faller, Lakeland
- Offensive: Austin Damaschke, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: Billy Dixon, Benedictine
Week of October 10-16
- Defensive: Ben Lockton, Benedictine
- Offensive: Jake Koehler, Concordia Chicago
- Special Teams: Billy Dixon, Benedictine
Week of October 3-9
- Defensive: Tony Faller, Lakeland
- Offensive: Joseph Paul, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: John Borsellino, Benedictine
Week of September 26-October 2
- Defensive: Tyler Schoen, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Offensive: John Borsellino, Benedictine
- Special Teams: Brett Youngbeck, Wisconsin Lutheran
Week of September 19-25
- Defensive: Matt Rolf, Concordia Chicago
- Offensive: Dylan Van Straten, Lakeland
- Special Teams: no nominations
Week of September 12-18
- Defensive: Ethan Rosen, Maranatha
- Offensive: Jesse Muldrow, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Special Teams: Anthony Beres, Rockford
Week of September 5-11
- Defensive: Kevin Glock, Aurora
- Offensive: Jake Koehler, Concordia Chicago
- Special Teams: Anthony Beres, Rockford
Week of August 29-September 4
- Defensive: Matthew Morrison, Maranatha
- Offensive: John Borsellino, Benedictine
- Special Teams: Billy Dixon, Benedictine