Week of November 5-11
- Defensive: C.J. Dear, Concordia Chicago
- Offensive: Josh Stodola, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Special Teams: no nominations
Week of October 29-November 4
- Defensive: Ben Lockton, Benedictine
- Offensive: Austin Damaschke, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: EJ Johnson, Rockford
Week of October 22-28
- Defensive: Shawn Corwin, Aurora
- Offensive: Zach Shaw, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Special Teams: no nominations
Week of October 15-21
- Defensive: Chris Thompson, Concordia Chicago
- Offensive: Matthew Botello, Rockford
- Special Teams: Joe Paul, Concordia Wisconsin
Week of October 8-14
- Defensive: L.J. Stolarski, Benedictine
- Offensive: Andrew Maddox, Concordia Chicago
- Special Teams: Brett Youngbeck, Wisconsin Lutheran
Week of October 1-7
- Defensive: Michael Bajc, Aurora
- Offensive: Jimmy Bevell, Aurora
- Special Teams: Fernando Albarran, Aurora
Week of September 24-30
- Defensive: John Palese, Concordia Wisconsin
- Offensive: Josh Stodola, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Special Teams: Hunter Breuing, Concordia Wisconsin
Week of September 10-16
- Defensive: Jacob Arnold, Rockford
- Offensive: Jake Koehler, Concordia Chicago
- Special Teams: John Borsellino, Benedictine
Week of September 3-9
- Defensive: Ben Lockton, Benedictine
- Offensive: Josh Stodola, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Special Teams: Donavin Tucker, Wisconsin Lutheran
Week of August 27-September 2
- Defensive: Ethan Lane, Maranatha
- Offensive: Jake Koehler, Concordia Chicago
- Special Teams: Josh Ruppel, Wisconsin Lutheran