Week of November 11-17
- Defensive: Darren Harms, Aurora
- Offensive: Austin Damaschke, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: Ramsey Riehl, Lakeland
Week of November 4-10
- Defensive: Tanner Behnke, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Offensive: LaCurt Evans, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: David Gonzalez, Concordia Wisconsin
Week of October 28-November 3
- Defensive: Alex Davis, Benedictine
- Offensive: Artie Monaco, Benedictine
- Special Teams: David Gonzalez, Concordia Wisconsin
Week of October 21-27
- Defensive: Dylan Rose, Benedictine
- Offensive: Austin Damaschke, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: Trevor Walzak, Benedictine
Week of October 14-20
- Defensive: Taylor Witty, Concordia Wisconsin
- Offensive: Austin Damaschke, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: David Gonzalez, Concordia Wisconsin
Week of October 7-13
- Defensive: Cody Thurber, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Offensive: Mike Reeves, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Special Teams: Artie Monaco, Benedictine
Week of September 30-October 6
- Defensive: Luke Scheuerlein, Concordia Wisconsin
- Offensive: Dylan Van Straten, Lakeland
- Special Teams: Tanner Wilcox, Aurora
Week of September 23-29
- Defensive: no nominations
- Offensive: Jake Apple, Aurora
- Special Teams: no nominations
Week of September 16-22
- Defensive: Cody Lemke, Lakeland
- Offensive: Blake Anders, Benedictine
- Special Teams: R.J. Bain, Benedictine
Week of September 9-15
- Defensive: Jarrett Lecas, Benedictine
- Offensive: Michael McNulty, Benedictine
- Special Teams: Hunter Breunig, Concordia Wisconsin
Week of September 2-8
- Defensive: Brandon Haase, Aurora
- Offensive: Delroy Russell, Rockford
- Special Teams: Ryan Mizgate, Aurora