Week of November 10-16
- Defensive: Tanner Behnke, Wisconsin Lutheran
- Offensive: Artie Monaco, Benedictine
- Special Teams: Alex Foster, Wisconsin Lutheran
Week of November 3-9
- Defensive: Seth Swinehart, Rockford
- Offensive: Greg German, Benedictine
- Special Teams: Brandon Pribbernow, Lakeland
Week of October 27-November 2
- Defensive: Rodney Nichols, Bendictine
- Offensive: Jakari Cammon, Concordia Chicago
- Special Teams: Matt Grams, Wisconsin Lutheran
Week of October 20-26
- Defensive: Yaphay Harvey, Lakeland
- Offensive: Ryan Keener, Benedictine
- Special Teams: Daeon Farris, Wisconsin Lutheran
Week of October 13-19
- Defensive: Reginald Haynes, Rockford
- Offensive: Austin Damaschke, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: Artie Monaco, Benedictine
Week of October 6-12
- Defensive: Jestin Heimbruch, Wiscosin Lutheran
- Offensive: Austin Damaschk, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: no nominations
Week of September 29-October 5
- Defensive: Yaphay Harvey, Lakeland
- Offensive: Garret Wenzelburger, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: Jacob Plevell, Bendictine
Week of September 22-28
- Defensive: Fred Fielding, Lakeland
- Offensive: Michael Esiobu, Lakeland
- Special Teams: no nominations
Week of September 15-21
- Defensive: Tyson Burch, Concordia Chicago
- Offensive: Aaron Nixon, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: Peyton Petersen, Lakeland
Week of September 8-14
- Defensive: Jacob Gorsuch, Rockford
- Offensive: Garrett Wenzelburger, Concordia Wisconsin
- Special Teams: David Gonzalez, Concordia Wisconsin
Week of September 1-7
- Defensive: Pascal Sylla, Rockford
- Offensive: Andrew Stochl, Rockford
- Special Teams: David Gonzalez, Concordia Wisconsin